Internet Marketing Journal UK

23 Nov, 2007

FeedBurner not giving link love by using 302 HTTP redirects

Posted by: Mercury Thread In: Firefox| Google PageRank| IMJUK| Internet Marketing| Links| RSS| SEO| Search Engine Optimization| Wordpress

I’ve posted before about how great FeedBurner is for getting your feed subscriber stats. However I do feel that it has a major failing - it doesn’t give you your link love back. And as someone who loves the free links that you can get from using your RSS feed appropriately having a feed in feedburner becomes a non option.

HTTP Header Redirects

My first encounter with HTTP header redirects was when I started reading about ways to steal traffic from domains in the Google SERPs by using 302 redirects. A 302 HTTP header redirect indiciates that the page you requested has been temporarily moved to a new location and your browser will take you to the temporary location. A 301 HTTP header indiciates that the page you requested has been permanently moved to a new location. If you placed a 302 redirect to a well ranking page - under certain circumstances - you could get their traffic from the Google SERPs.

Following this Matt Cutts started offering advice on HTTP redirects and header responses, here and here, the whole SEO world took note. Discussions started about which headers we should all be sending for pages that had moved from one location to another. Google would only pass on all your link based variables to a new location is the redirect took place by a 301 and only the page that the redirect resolved to would get the creedit - and the rankings.

If you don’t use a 301 HTTP header redirect from an old page location to a new one you don’t get your PageRank passed on!

It would appear that either FeedBurner have been very lazy or were listening hard and purposefully developed a system to stop users of their RSS system getting any link love.

FeedBurner Redirects are 302 redirects!

In your normal feed, say that from WordPress, you get a link in your RSS which points to your page - it’s a real link. If you use a FeedBurner feed your link looks the same and resolves to the same final point but is sent to an intermediate page within the FeedBurner website and redirected. As they use a 302 redirect you don’t get your link love :(
I’ve used the Live HTTP Headers Plugin for Firefox to get the headers for the RSS feed over at Geeks Are Sexy.

FeedBurner Plugin for WordPress

If you use the FeedBurner plugin for wordpress it automatically redirects your on-site feed to your feedburner feed - completely removing your potential for getting link love.

I do have a feedburner URL which I use for certain things but I’ve also made sure that I’m in complete control of the feeds that I output. I output onsite - the auto-discovery feed as being my real feed and I syndicate the real feed but I make the feedburner feed available as I get some benefits such as auto-pinging some traffic sources (I was having some problems with WordPress on this server and my out going pings weren’t working and this seemed like a quick fix).

Anyway if you use FeedBurner use it wisely do not rely on it as the best way of getting your information out onto the web - like every service it’s a tool within your arsenal and never rely on one tool too much.

10 Responses to "FeedBurner not giving link love by using 302 HTTP redirects"

1 | Jonathan Dingman

November 24th, 2007 at 4:57 am

Avatar

I fail to see a reason why FeedBurner would even want to give the link love in the first place.

FeedBurner is owned by Google now and Google doesn’t care about your search rankings being any higher than they already are. They just want to take your money through AdWords. Small publishers, large publishers, anymore, they’ll take your money and run.

2 | nsm seo

November 25th, 2007 at 10:31 pm

Avatar

I think you mentioned this to me before, regarding the mashups, its good advice.

Copnsider it sphunn. :)

4 | nsm seo

November 26th, 2007 at 11:52 pm

Avatar

Mike there is a way to disable the 302 redirect and go straight for the 301 with FeedBurner. Thanks to our good buddies at sphinn.

http://blogs.feedburner.com/feedburner/archives/2007/04/whats_up_with_that_vol_3_seo_1.php

Hope this helps.

5 | Mercury Thread

November 27th, 2007 at 2:52 pm

Avatar

Cheers for the heads up guys. Am going to dive into feedburner and see if I want to turn this functionality on and start using feed burner - the results I’m starting to get for feeds from google webmaster tools have been encouraging but I think that feedburner stats may just give me some extra data to work with.

6 | How to Promote Your Blog's Feed | Stephan Miller

March 9th, 2008 at 4:32 am

Avatar

[...] this could be good or worthless and defeat the whole purpose of this post, I went searching to see if Feedburner links pass rank. It turns out they do and they don’t depending on how they are set up. And mine weren’t [...]

7 | Chris Egan

March 18th, 2008 at 5:53 pm

Avatar

I second Jonathons thoughts, re Google and Feedburner, but sadly things are hit an miss, and in constant flux. I would like to see this working on all links not just some. Ease of use should be a Google byword.

8 | Internet Marketing Blog » What to do if Wordpress blog pings are not working?

March 30th, 2008 at 3:35 pm

Avatar

[...] Once your set up click on the Pro options link and change your feed to be for search engines (this gets rid of the 302 redirect problem and changes them to 301’s - you gotta keep your link love going). Select Pingomatic and Google Blog Ping from the list of [...]

9 | James

October 1st, 2008 at 12:41 pm

Avatar

Indeed as Dave and other’s have mentioned you can set feedburner to pass the juice.

I have recently written an article detailing exactly how to change Feedburner fee to 301 redirects

10 | Pratish

November 8th, 2008 at 2:06 pm

Avatar

I’m a little new to the whole blogging thing and I’ve just signed up with feedburner .. am a bit concerned that I’m getting the short end of the stick having read this post!

I am using feedburner mostly as an easy way to allow my blog readers to receive their new daily cartoons by email subscription - is there a more effective way to send these emails out and manage the subscriptions without using feedburner? Would really appreciate your advice!

Comment Form


  • Pratish: I'm a little new to the whole blogging thing and I've just signed up with feedburner .. am a bit concerned that I'm getting the short end of the stick
  • Catering Equipment Contractors: I always use the tools at iwebtool they have over 30 free tools to use similar to this one, howver, this is byfar the best DC tool I have seen thanks!
  • Richard Garcia: SEO Marketing can only be considered as effective if it generates large number of visitor traffic to the site being promoted. Internet marketing stati

About the IMJUK

This is a blog about all things to do with Internet Marketing in the UK. Its currently got a few contributors and we'll be expanding as soon as we can find more able bodied folk to talk about search engine optimisation, pay per click marketing, affiliate marketing, social media, banner advertising and web design.